Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Laura's avatar

Thank you for your continued vigilance and reporting on these topics-many of which would get no coverage but for your newsletter. Thank you for your advocacy and education!

Expand full comment
Paul Burstein's avatar

I'm glad to see you responding to the attack on the Antisemitism Task Force Report.

So far as I can tell, the Jewish critics highlight three points. First, the survey is wrong because it doesn't find enough "viewpoint diversity"--that is, the critics are convinced that there are large numbers of Jews at the UW who agree with them that the Report somehow doesn't find. In other words, the critics believe that surely must be large numbers of Jews who want Israel destroyed and vast numbers of Jews killed.

Second, they keep saying that anti-Zionism is not antisemsitism--just because you want Israel to be destroyed and vast numbers of Jews killed, you're not an antisemite.

Third, they can't understand why some Jewish organizations don't want to have anything to do with them. They want to be accepted--even liked.

If anyone can explain to me why people who call for mass murder believe that their views must be widely shared, and then don't understand why some other Jews don't like them, you've got my full attention. If the issue weren't so serious, the critics would seem pathetic more than anything else.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts